* Denotes judicial appointment
District 1
- Baker, H.G. – 1908 *
- Owen, Thomas H. – 1908 *
- Richardson, D.A. – 1910 *
- Armstrong, James R. – 1910 | 1914
- Bessey, E.S. – 1920
- Davenport, James S. – 1926 | 1932 | 1938
- Jones, Dick – 1940 * | 1944 | 1950
- Nix, Kirksey – 1956 | 1962 | 1968
- Simms, Robert D. – 1971 *
- Bliss, C.F., Jr. – 1972 * | 1974
- Cornish, Tom R. – 1977 *| 1978 | 1980
- Parks, Ed, Jr. – 1984 *| 1986
- Chapel, Charles S. – 1993 * | 1994 | 1998 | 2004
- Smith, Clancy – 2010 * | 2016
- Kuehn, Dana – 2016 * | 2017 | 2021
- Musseman, William – 2022*
District 2
- Furman, Henry M. – 1908 *| 1910 | 1912
- Brett, Rutherford – 1916 *
- Matson, Smith C. – 1917 * | 1918
- Edwards, Thomas A. – 1924 | 1930
- Barefoot, Bert B. – 1936 | 1942 | 1948
- Powell, John C. – 1949 *| 1954
- Bussey, Hez J. – 1960 | 1966 | 1972 | 1978 | 1984
- Johnson, Charles A. – 1989 *| 1990 | 1996 | 2002 | 2008
- Hudson, Robert L. – 2015 *
District 3
- Lumpkin, Gary L. – 1988 * | 1990 | 1996 | 2002 | 2008 | 2014
District 4
- Doyle, Thomas H. – 1908 * | 1910 | 1916 | 1922
- Chappell, Will H. – 1928
- Doyle, Thomas H. – 1934 | 1940
- Brett, John A. – 1946 | 1952 | 1956
- Johnson, Joe E. – 1963 *
- Brett, Tom – 1964 | 1970 | 1976 | 1982 | 1988
- Strubar, Rita M. – 1993 *| 1994 | 2000
- Johnson, Arlene – 2005 *| 2006 | 2012
- Rowland, Scott – 2016 *| 2017
District 5
- Lane, James F. – 1988 * | 1990 | 1994
- Lile, Steve – 1999 * | 2000
- Lewis, David – 2005 * | 2006 | 2012 | 2018